Google Home Speaker vs Echo Dot Max: Gemini or Alexa+ for $99?
Google Home Speaker and Echo Dot Max both cost $99.99. What each does, the September 30 Gemini for Home update, the monthly AI cost, and which to buy.
Google's new smart speaker costs $99.99 and runs on Gemini. Amazon sells a speaker at the same price with the new Alexa. There is also a monthly fee that most people miss.
I have not tested these. Everything comes from Google's and Amazon's official pages and release notes.
▶ WATCH ON YOUTUBEWatch the video
▶ WATCH ON YOUTUBEFull video
Side by side
| Google Home Speaker | Amazon Echo Dot Max | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $99.99 | $99.99 |
| Sound | One full-range driver, 360° sound | Woofer + tweeter, "nearly 3x the bass" of the old Echo Dot |
| Smart home | Matter hub, Thread border router | Zigbee, Matter and Thread hub |
| Assistant | Gemini for Home | Alexa+ |
| AI cost | Google Home Premium $10 a month after 6 free months | Free with Prime, $19.99 a month without |
| Home theatre | Pair two with a Google TV Streamer | Up to five with a Fire TV, coming soon |
| Best fit | Nest and Android | Ring and Prime |
Google Home Speaker
Google calls it the first speaker built for Gemini.
- About 3.5 inches tall, under one pound, wrapped in knit fabric
- Four colours: Porcelain, Hazel, Jade and Berry
- A light ring that shows when it listens, thinks and answers
- Three microphones and a real switch on the back to turn them off
- Wi-Fi 6 and Bluetooth
Gemini for Home
It runs Gemini, not the old Google Assistant. You do not need exact commands.
- Three things at once: "Dim the kitchen lights, play some music and set a timer."
- Logic: "Turn off every light except the bedrooms."
- Change your mind mid-sentence: "Turn off the coffee maker. Wait, I meant turn it on."
- Describe, do not name: "Set the living room lights to the colour of the ocean."
- Follow-ups: ask for the news, then "tell me more about the second story".
The September 30 update
- It hears you better when people are talking in the background.
- Everyday commands (lights, music, alarms, timers) answer faster.
- It understands homes where people speak three languages.
- Find My Phone is more reliable.
- Routines follow typed commands as well as spoken ones.
A small fix I like: slide a light to zero and it now turns fully off. Google calls Gemini for Home early access, so it is still changing.
The monthly cost
The best Gemini features need Google Home Premium.
| Plan | Price | Adds |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | $10 a month or $100 a year | Gemini Live, "Help me create" automations |
| Advanced | $20 a month or $200 a year | Camera search, daily home summaries |
The speaker includes six months of Premium. Premium is also included with Google AI Pro. Without it, you still get smart home control, music and quick answers.
So after the free months, the real price is at least $10 a month.
Amazon Echo Dot Max
- Two speakers and sound that adapts to the room
- A new Amazon-designed AI chip
- Alexa+ remembers a conversation across days and can get things done: order takeout, book a table, call a ride
- Works with Ring cameras
- Alexa+ is free with Amazon Prime
Only Amazon also supports Zigbee, an older standard many devices still use.
The catch
- These are the companies' own claims. Nobody here ran a test.
- The best features on both sides are moving to monthly plans.
- Some Gemini features start in a few countries first.
- Prices can change, so check both stores.
Which one to buy
| You | Buy |
|---|---|
| Already use Nest cameras or an Android phone | Google Home Speaker |
| Pay for Prime | Echo Dot Max, because the AI is free |
| Care most about music | Echo Dot Max, on paper |
| Want to search your camera video by asking | Google, with the Advanced plan |
Links
- Full video: https://youtu.be/HtsN36Bk8Z0
- Google Store: https://store.google.com/us/product/google_home_speaker
- Google Home release notes: https://support.google.com/googlehome/answer/15962877
- Amazon, Alexa+ for Prime members: https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/devices/alexa-plus-available-free-prime-members-us
- Apple's answer: Apple HomeView explained
Which one would you pick?
Not a hands-on test. Not sponsored by or affiliated with Google or Amazon.


